Brooklyn Pizza- *, 59 min.
Easily the worst of our six options. The crust was tough and chewy, and the pizza generally lacked flavor. And our $13.20 small pizza somehow turned into a $17.85 charge.
Cinelli's Pizza- ***, 64 min.
Liberally seasoned with herbs and spices—like eating an evergreen tree. While the pizza was good, the overall experience was tainted by the angry delivery man.
Domino's Pizza- ****, 24 min.
The first to arrive, and the first to be devoured. The crust is complimented with a delicious garlic seasoning that makes this pizza an easy pick for second best.
Enzo's Pizza Co.- *****, 37 min.
This pizza may be quite small, but it packs more flavor punch than all the others combined. Simply delicious. By far the best tasting of the six.
Papa John's Pizza- ***, 25 min.
The only pizza shipped with accessories. Just what you’d expect from Papa John’s. Pretty good and pretty cheap.
Randy's Pizza- ****, 62 min.
This pizza arrived a bit cold, but was still quite flavorful. The crust is nothing special, but the pizza as a whole is very well balanced. A good overall choice.
Get The Chronicle straight to your inbox
Signup for our weekly newsletter. Cancel at any time.