DSO situation should spur further discussion

Allie Vergotz's column, "DSG off-key," (Feb. 5) oversimplifies a nuanced matter. The denial of Duke Symphony Orchestra's request for "Chartered" status marked the denouement of a long process that unearthed important issues and attitudes existing in the Student Organization Finance Committee's chartering system. On DSO's behalf, we express gratitude for changes SOFC made to meet our needs. However, we would like to continue this pertinent discussion of the philosophy under which Duke Student Government operates.

The debate instigated by DSO's appeal cannot be reduced merely to the senators' lack of understanding of the by-laws; it was a reflection of the ambiguity of the situation. By nature of our organization, it is necessary to hold auditions. However, all concerts and events are open to anyone and everyone who will come. We will gladly find a role for anyone who wishes to be a part of our organization; we not only strive to be as inclusive as possible, but it is in our best interest to do so.

As Vergotz noted, the only exceptional difference between "Recognized" and "Chartered" groups is, "the latter may submit an application for an annual budget," allowing them to request money for both programming and material funds. From DSG's perspective, "selective" groups are not eligible for such funds because the public would not have access to any material goods the group may purchase. But what group, selective or not, does provide easy access of its property to the public?

The question, regarding the spirit of the selectivity by-law, remains: Should a student organization that embraces and upholds Duke's values and endeavors to provide a public good be restricted from applying for an annual budget? This by-law was put in place to prevent groups that are selective in their membership from taking advantage of DSG to fund activities closed to their group. This is clearly not the case with DSO.

It is in Duke's best interest to probe the reasoning behind these by-laws and to reexamine the groups DSG chooses to fiscally endorse.

Talya Lieberman

Trinity '07

Duke Symphony Orchestra Committee President